Adapting to Ambiguous Information
In a circle, one person poses a problem, the next proposes a nonsensical solution, and the third links them together. Builds comfort with uncertainty.
Structure
Setup
Participants stand or sit in a circle. Groups of 6-20 work best. No materials needed.
The Pattern
The exercise runs in three-person cycles around the circle:
- Player A poses a real or invented problem. It should be concrete enough to be specific but open enough to not have an obvious answer. ("We're running out of space in the office." "Our two strongest team members don't get along.")
- Player B immediately proposes a nonsensical or absurd solution with conviction. The solution does not need to be practical - in fact, it should be clearly impractical. ("Put the desks in the parking lot." "Have them fight it out in mime.")
- Player C connects the problem and the absurd solution with genuine logic. They find a way to make the nonsense make sense. ("Actually, temporary outdoor spaces are a real trend - remote-first companies use 'hub zones' to...")
After player C speaks, Player B becomes A, C becomes B, and a new person from the circle steps in as C.
Timing
Run for 15-20 minutes or until all participants have cycled through each role at least once.
How to Teach It
How to Explain It
"Three roles in a cycle: the problem, the absurd solution, and the connector. Problem-poser: give us something real. Solution-giver: make it ridiculous but say it with confidence. Connector: make it make sense anyway. The connector is the hard job."
Why It Matters
This exercise directly trains the capacity to work with ambiguous, incomplete, or surprising information - a daily reality in most organizational contexts. The "connector" role is particularly demanding: it requires the participant to treat an absurd input seriously, find any thread of coherent logic, and follow it forward. This is precisely the cognitive move required when organizational conditions shift unexpectedly and teams must find a path forward from where they actually are rather than where they planned to be.
Common Coaching Notes
- The absurd solution should be committed. If Player B hedges or apologizes for the nonsense, the connector's job becomes too easy. Encourage: "Say it like it's the most obvious answer in the world."
- The connector should not dismiss. If Player C starts with "well, that doesn't make sense but..." the exercise fails. The goal is genuine engagement with the absurd starting point.
- Speed helps. Run the cycle quickly. Long pauses for problem-crafting slow the momentum. Encourage immediate response.
Debrief Questions
- What did you notice in the connector role?
- When did you find an unexpected thread of logic?
- Where in your work do you face situations that feel like the absurd solution - something you must work with even if it doesn't seem to make sense?
In Applied Settings
Organizational Context
Adapting to Ambiguous Information addresses a pervasive organizational challenge: teams that receive unclear, contradictory, or surprising information from leadership, clients, or the environment often stall or revert to previous approaches rather than adapting quickly. This exercise provides a low-stakes, repeatable practice structure for developing the adaptive cognitive flexibility that high-ambiguity environments demand.
Workplace Relevance
In most organizational contexts, the "nonsensical solution" maps to the kind of inputs teams regularly receive: unclear directives, incomplete data, sudden pivots, or requests that don't align with the team's existing logic. The exercise trains participants to find workable paths forward from imperfect starting points rather than waiting for clarity that may not arrive. This is especially relevant in fast-moving industries, startup environments, and any organization that is genuinely changing faster than its processes can keep up with.
Team and Meeting Use
The exercise works well as a workshop warm-up before a team session focused on problem-solving, strategy, or change management. It primes the group's associative thinking and reduces the implicit expectation that problems must be fully defined before solutions are attempted. In longer training programs, it can be revisited as a processing tool: "Let's run this with a real problem from the organization."
Debrief for Transfer
Facilitators can use the exercise to surface the team's existing approach to ambiguity: "How does your team typically respond when the information you receive doesn't match your expectations? What do you do first?" This connects the exercise experience to real organizational behavior.
Skills Developed
Worth Reading
See all books →
Business Improv
Experiential Learning Exercises to Train Employees
Val Gee
Pirate Robot Ninja
An Improv Fable
Billy Merritt; Will Hines
Group Improvisation
The Manual of Ensemble Improv Games
Peter Campbell Gwinn; Charna Halpern
When I Say This, Do You Mean That?
Enhancing Communication
Cherie Kerr; Julia Sweeney
The Improv Mindset
Change Your Brain. Change Your Business.
Gail Montgomery; Bruce T. Montgomery
Brain Disruption
Radical Innovation in Business Through Improv
Bruce Montgomery; Gail Montgomery
Related Exercises
Associatioin Chain
Association Chain is a circle exercise in which each player says a word inspired by the previous player's word, building a rapid chain of free associations. The exercise trains spontaneous, uncensored responses and reveals the connective leaps that drive improvised scene work. Speed is essential to prevent intellectual filtering.
Arm Tangle
Arm Tangle is a group problem-solving exercise in which players stand in a circle, reach across to grasp the hands of two different people, and then work together to untangle the resulting knot without releasing their grip. Also known as the Human Knot, the exercise builds group communication, spatial reasoning, and patient collaborative problem-solving.
Patterns
Patterns is an applied-improv concentration exercise documented by Val Hohn in *Putting Improv to Work*. Six to twelve participants stand in a circle and learn three fixed pointing patterns, then try to keep all three running at the same time. The exercise trains attention, clear sending and receiving, and the group's ability to recover when one thread drops.
Check-In
Group sits or stands in a circle and each person speaks briefly about how they are arriving. No interruptions. Can be enhanced with imaginary catch between speakers.
Bappety Boo
Bappety Boo is a focus and elimination exercise in which the person in the center of a circle points to someone and counts to a set number. The pointed-to player and their neighbors must complete an assigned physical task before the count finishes. Players who fail are eliminated or take the center. The game sharpens reaction time and group attention.
Acceptance
Acceptance is an applied improv exercise in which participants hear a new location, answer together with "Yes, let's," and immediately populate that environment as people or objects inside it. The exercise turns acceptance into visible behavior: participants must receive the new reality, enter it quickly, and adjust when someone else has already chosen the role they wanted.
How to Reference This Page
The Improv Archive. (2026). Adapting to Ambiguous Information. Retrieved March 17, 2026, from https://improvarchive.org/exercises/adapting-to-ambiguous-information
The Improv Archive. "Adapting to Ambiguous Information." The Improv Archive, 2026. https://improvarchive.org/exercises/adapting-to-ambiguous-information.
The Improv Archive. "Adapting to Ambiguous Information." The Improv Archive, 2026, https://improvarchive.org/exercises/adapting-to-ambiguous-information. Accessed March 17, 2026.
The Improv Archive is a systemically maintained repository. The archive itself acts as the corporate author.